Archived record Archived record page of the former CAB Direct database. Not affiliated with its current publisher.
Archive · Agriculture · Record 20063000808

Effect of different kinds of fertilizer on the yield and physical and chemical status of soil in SRI

This 2005 journal article compared fertilizer strategies within the System of Rice Intensification while keeping the supplied amounts of N, P2O5 and K2O equal. It examined rice grain yield, fertilizer use, and soil physical and chemical conditions, placing the findings within the broader context of nutrient-management research.

What the study did and found

The original publication is titled “Effect of different kinds of fertilizer on the yield and physical and chemical status of soil in SRI.” He Yang-Dong and Ma Jun compared different fertilizer types in rice (Oryza sativa) grown under the System of Rice Intensification while supplying equal amounts of N, P2O5 and K2O. The study reported that coordinated chemical and organic fertilization promoted plant development, increased grain yield, improved measured soil physical and chemical conditions, and increased fertilizer utilization. These findings highlight the relationship between fertilizer source, crop performance and soil condition under SRI management.

Why it is cited

The paper forms part of the early research literature on fertilizer management within the System of Rice Intensification. Its specific contribution is the comparison of fertilizer sources under equal N, P2O5 and K2O supply while considering both crop yield and soil condition.

Where the evidence stands

Later evidence supports the general value of combining organic and mineral nutrient sources in rice systems. A 2021 meta-analysis of integrated nutrient management reported modestly higher rice yield and improved soil organic carbon and microbial biomass compared with mineral NPK alone, while broader rice meta-analyses have also found improvements in soil properties under organic or combined fertilization. Evidence on SRI remains context-dependent: a meta-analysis of 72 field studies found that yield responses varied with soil fertility, with stronger benefits on highly weathered infertile soils than on more fertile soils. The historical study is therefore consistent with a broader body of research showing that nutrient-source combinations can influence rice yield, nutrient use and soil condition.

The topic today

Current rice nutrient-management research treats fertilizer source, nutrient rate, soil condition, water management and environmental losses as interacting factors rather than isolated choices. Recent meta-analyses continue to report potential yield and nitrogen-use benefits from combined organic and inorganic fertilization, while showing that outcomes vary with application rate, soil type, experiment duration and the environmental objective being measured. In SRI, fertilizer management is also one component alongside planting density, seedling management, irrigation and weeding. The 2005 paper remains useful as an early field result on nutrient-source coordination and contributes to the wider understanding of how integrated fertilization strategies can support rice productivity and soil management.