Research · Explainer

Impostor syndrome and why some people doubt their success

Impostor syndrome describes a pattern in which people doubt that success reflects their ability because they discount evidence of competence and attribute achievement to luck, effort or other people’s overestimation, even when performance is objectively strong. In research, the term impostor phenomenon is often preferred because the experience is not a recognised clinical diagnosis and can vary across situations.

This article traces the concept from its 1978 description to modern measurement and workplace research. It compares systematic reviews and empirical studies on prevalence, self-evaluation, discrimination, career context and interventions, while separating recurring associations from claims the evidence cannot yet support.

Professional at a desk with awards, reflecting on success and self-doubt
A successful professional reflects on achievements while still doubting her competence Editorial illustration

What impostor syndrome means in research

The phrase impostor syndrome is widely used, but the research literature is less settled than the label suggests. Most studies describe impostor feelings as a mismatch between external evidence of competence and an internal belief that success is undeserved, fragile or caused by luck, unusually hard work or other people overestimating ability. The central idea is therefore not simple modesty: it is difficulty incorporating evidence of success into a stable view of one’s own competence.

From the 1978 description to a broader construct

Clance and Imes introduced the term impostor phenomenon in 1978 after clinical and educational work with more than 150 high-achieving women, many of whom held advanced degrees or had strong academic and professional records (Clance and Imes, 1978). Their account emphasised persistent self-doubt, discounting of achievement and fear that others would eventually discover an assumed lack of ability. The original sample was narrow, however, so the paper could describe a pattern without establishing how common it was in the wider population.

Later studies broadened the construct beyond high-achieving women. Kolligian and Sternberg’s 1991 work on perceived fraudulence linked the experience with self-criticism, depressive tendencies, social anxiety, achievement pressure and self-monitoring, while Leary and colleagues in 2000 tested how self-perceptions and beliefs about other people’s appraisals contribute to impostor experiences (Kolligian and Sternberg, 1991; Leary et al., 2000). These studies helped move the topic from a clinical observation towards a measurable psychological construct, but they also introduced different definitions and scales.

Why the word syndrome can be misleading

Calling the experience a syndrome can imply a discrete disorder with agreed diagnostic criteria. That is not how the evidence base is organised: Mak and colleagues’ 2019 systematic review described impostor phenomenon as non-diagnosable and found four main self-report measures, with no established gold standard because dimensionality and psychometric evidence remained inconsistent (Mak et al., 2019). For this reason, the terms impostor phenomenon, impostor feelings and impostor thoughts describe the construct more precisely than language that implies a medical diagnosis.

This distinction also matters because impostor experiences may fluctuate. A person can have persistent self-doubting tendencies, yet feelings may intensify after a promotion, in a new institution or when entering a setting where status and competence are highly visible. Reviews of workplace research increasingly argue that both trait-like and state-like forms need to be considered rather than assuming a single fixed characteristic (Gullifor et al., 2024).

Why success can still feel undeserved

Research links doubts about deserved success to how people interpret achievements and anticipate others' judgements. Studies also distinguish more persistent self-evaluative tendencies from reactions that emerge in particular roles or situations (Leary et al., 2000; Gullifor et al., 2024).

Attribution, self-evaluation and fear of exposure

A repeated feature of impostor research is the way people explain their own success. The original account described participants who attributed achievements to luck, effort, charm, timing or mistakes in other people’s judgement rather than ability (Clance and Imes, 1978). Leary and colleagues later showed that impostorism involves not only negative self-evaluation but also beliefs about how others see the person, making the gap between private self-assessment and perceived external appraisal central to the experience (Leary et al., 2000).

Low self-esteem, fear of failure and fear of success are also frequently correlated with impostor feelings. In two studies involving university students and working professionals, Neureiter and Traut-Mattausch found that these factors were associated with stronger impostor feelings, which in turn were linked with poorer career planning and lower motivation to lead (Neureiter and Traut-Mattausch, 2016). Because the studies were largely correlational, they identify connected variables rather than proving a single causal chain from one personality factor to impostor feelings.

Other research examines self-talk and competitive anxiety in sport, including links between self-directed responses and fear of failure. Those findings concern sport-related anxiety rather than impostor phenomenon and should not be treated as direct evidence that one causes the other.

Trait-like tendencies and situation-specific states

Researchers disagree about whether impostor phenomenon is best understood as a stable disposition or a situation-sensitive state. Gullifor and colleagues reviewed 188 workplace-related scholarly works and argued that the literature has often treated the construct as a trait even though situational triggers can produce shorter-term fluctuations (Gullifor et al., 2024). A trait-state view can explain why some people report recurrent impostor feelings across settings while others mainly experience them during transitions or high-evaluation periods.

The distinction changes what counts as an explanation. Stable self-critical tendencies may make impostor feelings more likely, but an unfamiliar role, unclear performance standards, competitive comparison or belonging uncertainty can also matter. A sense of not deserving one’s place may therefore arise from different combinations of personal history, current demands and social context rather than from one universal mechanism.

What studies show about prevalence and measurement

Reported prevalence varies so widely that a single headline percentage can be misleading. Bravata and colleagues’ 2020 systematic review included 62 studies with 14,161 participants and found prevalence estimates from 9% to 82%, largely because studies used different instruments and cut-offs (Bravata et al., 2020). A 2026 meta-analysis of 34 studies and 9,550 medical students produced a pooled estimate of 49%, but heterogeneity was extremely high at I² = 95.6%, again showing that measurement choices strongly affect the result (Omar et al., 2026).

Study or review

Sample or evidence base

Main result

Key limitation

Clance & Imes, 1978

More than 150 high-achieving women

Described persistent intellectual fraudulence despite objective success

Clinical and educational observations in a narrow, mostly white female sample

Mak et al., 2019

18 measurement studies

Identified four major scales and no clear gold-standard measure

Psychometric reporting and construct dimensionality were inconsistent

Bravata et al., 2020

62 studies; 14,161 participants

Prevalence ranged from 9% to 82% and associations spanned many groups

Different scales and cut-offs limited comparability

Tewfik, 2022

4 studies; n = 3,603

Workplace impostor thoughts were associated with greater other-rated interpersonal effectiveness

Narrow workplace-thought construct is not identical to all impostor measures

Para et al., 2024

31 intervention studies

Training and counselling approaches were common, with heterogeneous reported effects

Designs and outcome measures were too varied for a single efficacy conclusion

Omar et al., 2026

34 studies; 9,550 medical students

Pooled prevalence 49%, with major differences by tool and subgroup

Medical-student focus and extreme heterogeneity limit generalisation

Measurement is not a minor technical issue here. Mak and colleagues found that common scales differ in their assumptions and that evidence for validity, reliability and dimensionality was uneven across studies (Mak et al., 2019). The 2026 medical-education meta-analysis reached a similar warning from a different direction: estimates changed significantly with the instrument used, suggesting that studies may not always be counting the same psychological experience (Omar et al., 2026).

For readers, the practical implication is that prevalence figures describe research samples under specific definitions, not a universally diagnosed population. A high score on a questionnaire can indicate stronger impostor feelings as defined by that instrument, but it does not by itself establish a disorder, a cause or a prognosis. Comparisons between professions, countries or demographic groups are strongest when the same validated measure and threshold are used consistently.

Who experiences impostor feelings and how context matters

Impostor feelings have been studied across genders, career stages and institutional settings. Findings suggest that their intensity and reported frequency depend partly on the context and on how researchers define and measure the phenomenon (Bravata et al., 2020; Gullifor et al., 2024).

Gender, career stage and achievement settings

The first paper focused on women, but later research does not support the idea that impostor feelings belong to one gender. Bravata and colleagues found the phenomenon across men and women and across age groups from adolescents to senior professionals, although prevalence varied by sample and instrument (Bravata et al., 2020). The 2026 medical-student meta-analysis found higher pooled estimates among women than men in that specific literature, but the authors also showed that region and measurement tool changed estimates substantially (Omar et al., 2026).

Transitions may be especially relevant because they create new standards and uncertainty about belonging. Entering university, professional training, leadership or a new job can increase comparison with highly selected peers while reducing access to familiar feedback. These settings do not prove that achievement itself causes impostor feelings; rather, they make competence visible and can amplify uncertainty when a person has not yet formed stable expectations about the new role.

Race, ethnicity and discrimination

Context is particularly important when the person also faces stereotypes or exclusion. In a 2017 study of racial and ethnic minority college students, Cokley and colleagues found that impostor feelings helped explain part of the relationship between perceived discrimination and mental-health outcomes (Cokley et al., 2017). This does not mean discrimination is reducible to an individual mindset; it shows that social experiences can interact with self-perceptions in ways that matter for distress.

A 2024 Annual Review article by Cokley and colleagues argued that research on racially and ethnically minoritised groups needs more culturally specific theory, diverse samples and measures that do not automatically treat the problem as located only within the individual (Cokley et al., 2024). That critique is important because a person’s uncertainty about belonging may sometimes reflect real signals from an environment, including stereotyping, tokenism or unequal evaluation, rather than a purely inaccurate internal belief.

Workplace climate and social evaluation

Workplace research adds another layer because organisations continuously communicate who is considered competent and who belongs. Gullifor and colleagues’ 2024 systematic review mapped antecedents and outcomes across 188 scholarly works and concluded that the field remains conceptually fragmented, with personal and contextual variables often studied in separate silos (Gullifor et al., 2024). Their trait-state framework argues that situations can trigger impostor experiences even when a person’s general level of self-doubt is relatively stable.

This perspective helps explain why identical achievements may feel secure in one setting and fragile in another. Clear criteria, credible feedback and inclusive norms can reduce ambiguity about performance, whereas inconsistent standards or chronic social comparison can make it harder to interpret success. The literature supports studying these environmental conditions alongside individual differences, but it is not yet strong enough to assign a fixed proportion of impostor feelings to either person or context.

Associations with wellbeing, careers and performance

Evidence connects impostor feelings with distress and career-related outcomes, but the findings do not describe a uniform effect on behaviour or performance. The distinction matters because most associations are correlational, whereas workplace studies have also examined interpersonal outcomes (Bravata et al., 2020; Tewfik, 2022).

Distress and career consequences

Across studies, stronger impostor feelings are repeatedly associated with anxiety, depressive symptoms, lower self-esteem and burnout, although these are correlations rather than proof that impostor feelings independently cause each outcome (Bravata et al., 2020). The overlap also raises a measurement question: some scales may partly capture general negative self-evaluation or distress, making it difficult to separate a distinct impostor construct from neighbouring psychological variables. That is one reason systematic reviews continue to emphasise construct clarity.

Career studies suggest that the experience can matter beyond mood. Neureiter and Traut-Mattausch found links with reduced career planning and motivation to lead across their student and working samples; reduced career striving was observed in the working sample, while career-striving results in students were mixed (Neureiter and Traut-Mattausch, 2016). Such findings are consistent with the idea that people who discount their competence may hesitate to pursue opportunities, but longitudinal studies are still needed to show how impostor feelings shape decisions over time rather than simply accompany career uncertainty.

Why the effects are not uniformly negative

The common story is that impostor feelings only undermine performance, yet recent workplace research is more nuanced. Tewfik tested workplace impostor thoughts across four studies with 3,603 participants and found that employees who more often believed others overestimated their competence were rated as more interpersonally effective, partly because they adopted a more other-focused orientation (Tewfik, 2022). The study did not show that impostor experiences are beneficial overall; it identified a possible interpersonal upside for a specific workplace construct.

That result is useful because it separates different outcomes. A person can feel uncertain and still perform competently, cooperate well or receive positive evaluations from others. It also cautions against assuming that visible confidence is a reliable measure of ability, while leaving open whether repeated self-doubt carries longer-term costs for wellbeing, effort or career choices.

What intervention studies can and cannot establish

Research on interventions is growing, but it is not yet comparable to an evidence base for a well-defined clinical treatment. Para and colleagues’ 2024 scoping review identified 31 studies addressing impostor phenomenon in professional contexts and found heterogeneous designs, interventions and outcome measures (Para et al., 2024). Training and counselling approaches were common, and many reports described favourable changes, but the diversity of methods prevented a single firm conclusion about which component works, for whom or for how long.

The review also highlights a conceptual problem: an intervention aimed at an individual may address self-appraisal, whereas a contextual account points towards group, educational or organisational conditions. If impostor feelings partly arise from ambiguous expectations, exclusion or repeated social comparison, changing only the person’s interpretation may leave relevant environmental drivers untouched. Current evidence therefore supports studying both personal and systemic approaches without treating either as a universally established solution.

Advice-oriented claims are therefore difficult to justify from the current evidence. Existing studies describe strategies that have been tested, but the literature does not establish a standardised programme for everyone who reports impostor feelings. The strongest conclusion is that intervention research remains heterogeneous and requires better controlled designs, clearer constructs and longer follow-up (Para et al., 2024).

What is established and what remains uncertain

Several points are well supported. Impostor feelings are a real and measurable psychological experience, they occur in multiple genders and professional or educational groups, and they are often associated with distress, lower self-esteem and career uncertainty (Bravata et al., 2020). Research also shows that social context matters, especially when discrimination, role transitions or workplace evaluation affect how people interpret belonging and competence (Cokley et al., 2017; Cokley et al., 2024).

The uncertain parts are equally important. There is no gold-standard measure, prevalence depends heavily on the scale and cut-off, and studies use overlapping terms for related but not identical constructs (Mak et al., 2019; Gullifor et al., 2024). Much of the evidence is cross-sectional, which limits causal claims about whether impostor feelings produce distress and career effects, result from them, or develop through reciprocal relationships.

Impostor feelings can persist alongside genuine competence, but the evidence does not support treating them as a single clinical disorder with one cause, one prevalence rate or one proven intervention.

The most defensible interpretation is therefore neither to dismiss the experience nor to medicalise it automatically. Impostor phenomenon is a useful research label for patterns of undeserved-success beliefs and fear of being overestimated, but its boundaries remain under active study. Newer reviews and meta-analyses continue to converge on the same priority: clearer definitions, better measurement, more longitudinal research and closer attention to the environments in which self-doubt develops (Gullifor et al., 2024; Omar et al., 2026).

Frequently asked questions

Is impostor syndrome a mental health diagnosis?

No. Research generally treats impostor phenomenon as a psychological experience or construct rather than a standalone clinical diagnosis. Systematic reviews also show that there is no agreed diagnostic threshold or gold-standard measure. Strong impostor feelings can coexist with anxiety, depression or burnout, but those conditions require separate assessment rather than being inferred from impostor feelings alone.

What is the difference between impostor syndrome and low self-esteem?

They overlap but are not identical. Low self-esteem is a broad negative evaluation of self-worth, whereas impostor feelings focus more specifically on competence, deserved success and the belief that other people may be overestimating ability. Studies often find the two are correlated, which is one reason researchers continue to test whether impostor measures capture a distinct construct.

Can men experience impostor syndrome?

Yes. Later studies have found impostor feelings in men and women across many educational and professional groups. Some samples report gender differences and others do not, while recent meta-analytic work shows that measurement tool, region and population can substantially change prevalence estimates. The original focus on high-achieving women does not define the boundary of the phenomenon.

Why do successful people feel like frauds?

Research points to several interacting explanations rather than one cause. People may discount ability and attribute success to luck, effort or others’ misjudgement, while fear of failure, self-criticism, role transitions and social evaluation can reinforce doubt. Workplace and discrimination research also indicates that uncertainty about belonging can reflect features of the surrounding environment, not only private beliefs.

How common is impostor syndrome?

There is no single reliable population rate. A 2020 systematic review reported estimates from 9% to 82%, while a 2026 meta-analysis of medical students produced a pooled estimate of 49%. Both bodies of work emphasise major differences between scales, thresholds and samples, making prevalence figures most informative when interpreted alongside the method used to define impostor phenomenon.

Sources

  1. Clance PR, Imes SA. The imposter phenomenon in high achieving women: Dynamics and therapeutic intervention. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice. 1978;15(3):241–247. DOI 10.1037/h0086006.
  2. Kolligian J Jr, Sternberg RJ. Perceived fraudulence in young adults: Is there an “imposter syndrome”? Journal of Personality Assessment. 1991;56(2):308–326. DOI 10.1207/s15327752jpa5602_10.
  3. Leary MR, Patton KM, Orlando AE, Funk WW. The impostor phenomenon: Self-perceptions, reflected appraisals, and interpersonal strategies. Journal of Personality. 2000;68(4):725–756. DOI 10.1111/1467-6494.00114.
  4. Neureiter M, Traut-Mattausch E. An inner barrier to career development: Preconditions of the impostor phenomenon and consequences for career development. Frontiers in Psychology. 2016;7:48. DOI 10.3389/fpsyg.2016.00048.
  5. Cokley K, Smith L, Bernard D, Hurst A, Jackson S, Stone S, Awosogba O, Saucer C, Bailey M, Roberts D. Impostor feelings as a moderator and mediator of the relationship between perceived discrimination and mental health among racial/ethnic minority college students. Journal of Counseling Psychology. 2017;64(2):141–154. DOI 10.1037/cou0000198.
  6. Mak KKL, Kleitman S, Abbott MJ. Impostor phenomenon measurement scales: A systematic review. Frontiers in Psychology. 2019;10:671. DOI 10.3389/fpsyg.2019.00671.
  7. Bravata DM, Watts SA, Keefer AL, Madhusudhan DK, Taylor KT, Clark DM, Nelson RS, Cokley KO, Hagg HK. Prevalence, predictors, and treatment of impostor syndrome: A systematic review. Journal of General Internal Medicine. 2020;35:1252–1275. DOI 10.1007/s11606-019-05364-1.
  8. Tewfik BA. The impostor phenomenon revisited: Examining the relationship between workplace impostor thoughts and interpersonal effectiveness at work. Academy of Management Journal. 2022;65(3):988–1018. DOI 10.5465/amj.2020.1627.
  9. Gullifor DP, Gardner WL, Karam EP, Noghani F, Cogliser CC. The impostor phenomenon at work: A systematic evidence-based review, conceptual development, and agenda for future research. Journal of Organizational Behavior. 2024;45(2):234–251. DOI 10.1002/job.2733.
  10. Cokley KO, Bernard DL, Stone-Sabali S, Awad GH. Impostor phenomenon in racially/ethnically minoritized groups: Current knowledge and future directions. Annual Review of Clinical Psychology. 2024;20:407–430. DOI 10.1146/annurev-clinpsy-081122-015724.
  11. Para E, Dubreuil P, Miquelon P, Martin-Krumm C. Interventions addressing the impostor phenomenon: A scoping review. Frontiers in Psychology. 2024;15:1360540. DOI 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1360540.
  12. Omar YM, Khattab YA, Abdelmageed A, Messak M, Mandour Y, Shabeeb AE, Zakaria AM, Abouelmagd ME. The impostor phenomenon construct in medical education: A meta-analysis of its prevalence and a critical appraisal of its measurement. Advances in Health Sciences Education. 2026. Online ahead of print. DOI 10.1007/s10459-026-10513-3.
Clara Whitmore

Clara Whitmore — author

Clara Whitmore writes with an editorial focus on historically important scientific studies, older research methods and the development of scientific concepts over time. At Cabdirect, Clara covers classic experiments, historical research and the changing interp...

Related